Benny’s Sandwiches · Full menu
The Menu
Built to order, every one. Bread comes in each morning, meats are sliced when you order, and the sauces are ours.
- Spicy
- Vegetarian
- VG Vegan
- GF Gluten-free bread available

Hot off the griddle
toasted, pressed, dripping
The Calabrese Meltnew!
$14.50
Hot capicola, soppressata, provolone and Calabrian chili honey, pressed on sourdough.
- Spicy
Hot Honey Ham
$12.75
Smoked ham, sharp cheddar, roasted peppers and hot honey on a toasted country loaf.
- Spicy
Benny's Cheesesteak
$14.00
Shaved ribeye, griddled onions and peppers, provolone, garlic butter roll.
Meatball Parm
$12.50
Beef and pork meatballs, Sunday gravy, mozzarella and parmesan on a toasted hero.
Cutlet Diablo
$13.25
Crispy chicken cutlet, Calabrian chili mayo, pickled cherry peppers, provolone.
- Spicy
Pastrami Reuben
$14.25
House-cured pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut and Russian dressing on griddled rye.
Cold cuts & classics
stacked high, sliced to order
The Big Benny
$13.25
Genoa salami, ham, provolone, shredded lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar on a seeded roll.
- GFGluten-free bread available
Turkey & Avo
$12.25
Roast turkey, smashed avocado, tomato and garlic mayo on a soft milk roll.
- GFGluten-free bread available
Roast Beef & Horsey
$13.00
Rare roast beef, sharp cheddar, horseradish cream and crispy shallots on an onion roll.
- GFGluten-free bread available
Lemon Tuna
$11.25
Olive-oil tuna, celery, capers, lemon aioli and butter lettuce on multigrain.
- GFGluten-free bread available
Benny's Chicken Salad
$11.50
Roast chicken, tarragon mayo, celery and toasted almonds on a butter croissant.
Pressed & melts
flattened on the plancha
The Prosciutto Press
$13.50
Prosciutto, arugula, aged parmesan and basil pesto, pressed flat on ciabatta.
The Cubano
$13.75
Mojo roast pork, ham, Swiss, pickles and yellow mustard on pressed Cuban bread.
Patty Melt
$13.00
Smashed beef patty, caramelized onions, Swiss and Benny's sauce on griddled rye.
Three-Cheese Grilled Cheese
$9.50
Cheddar, fontina and American on buttered sourdough. Add a cup of tomato soup for $3.
- Vegetarian
- GFGluten-free bread available
Garden side
no meat, no compromise
The Caprese Stack
$12.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, arugula and basil pesto on a flaky croissant.
- Vegetarian
Roasted Veg & Hummus
$11.00
Zucchini, peppers and eggplant with lemon hummus and feta on focaccia. Hold the feta to make it vegan.
- Vegetarian
- GFGluten-free bread available
Eggplant Parm
$12.25
Crispy eggplant, Sunday gravy, mozzarella and basil on a toasted hero.
- Vegetarian
Chickpea Smash
$10.75
Smashed chickpeas with dill and lemon, pickled red onion and sprouts on multigrain.
- VeganVG
- GFGluten-free bread available
Your call
Build your own
Starts at $10.50
Pick one of everything. Tell the counter how you like it.
Place an OrderBread
Sourdough, rye, ciabatta, seeded hero, multigrain, croissant (+$1), gluten-free (+$2)
Protein
Turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, roast chicken, tuna. Double it for $4
Cheese
Provolone, Swiss, cheddar, American, fresh mozzarella (+$1)
Toppings
Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, banana peppers, cherry peppers. All free
Sauce
Mayo, mustard, oil & vinegar, pesto, hot honey, Benny's sauce
Sides, soups, drinks and sweets
Sides
- Kettle chips$2.50
- House pickles, three spears$3.00
- Potato salad$4.00
- Macaroni salad$4.00
- Garlic parm fries$5.00
- Little green salad$5.50
Soups
- Tomato basilcup / bowl$4.50 / 7.00
- Chicken noodlecup / bowl$5.00 / 7.50
- Soup of the dayon the boardAsk
Drinks
- Fountain soda$2.75
- Fresh lemonade$3.50
- Black iced tea$3.00
- Cold brew$4.25
- Mexican Coke$3.75
- Bottled water$2.00
Sweets
- Brown butter chocolate chip cookie$3.25
- Cannoli, filled to order$4.00
- Lemon bar$3.50
- Every sandwich comes with a pickle spear.
- Swap any bread for gluten-free for $2.
- Make it a combo: chips or a side and a fountain drink, +$4.50.
- Allergies? Tell us before you order. Our kitchen handles wheat, dairy, eggs, soy, sesame and nuts.
Know what you want?
Place an Order